Ryan Deserves Your Scrutiny

I did not know much about Congressman Paul Ryan when Mitt Romney announced his choice for Vice President.  I had seen him doing one of those Republican responses to the President’s State of the Union, or some such speech.  From what I saw, he spoke well, looked young and fit, and did not produce in me any immediate, negative reaction.  He seemed a little unemotional, but, as a Catholic, I felt a certain affinity to  this young, energetic guy with the Irish name.  In my mind, how bad could he be?

Once I heard he was the choice for VP, I figured I better do my homework on Paul Ryan.  I read a good article in the New Yorker (http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2012/08/06/120806fa_fact_lizza), written just days prior to Saturday’s announcement.  I looked at information on his web page about his budget proposal.  I read articles on the webpage for the Tax Policy Center (http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/).  In searching these documents, I did so concerned that Mr. Ryan may harbor some of the same illusions as his  running mate about how easy it is for poor people to rise above their worsening economic circumstances.  I have written previously on my belief that Mr. Romney’s comments abroad suggested a lack of perspective when it came to the socio-economic forces standing in the way of upward mobility for many Americans.  Was Mr. Ryan another Social Darwinist using his personal life experience as a yardstick for measuring the upward mobility of his fellow Americans?

The answer seems to be a hardened “yes”.  In reaching that conclusion, I believe Mr. Ryan is probably a good man who believes fervently in the views he espouses so energetically.  But his record is unmistakable and deserves your scrutiny.  His current proposal radically cuts funding to Medicaid by making Medicaid a block grant program.  He proposes massive tax cuts with few details on where much of the money will come from to offset these cuts. His plans for a two-tiered personal income tax system with rates of 10% and 25% would drastically reduce revenue, but he refuses to consider higher rates for the wealthiest Americans.  This ensures that millions of poor and middle class voters will pick up the slack.  His plan for Medicare ventures raises serious questions about whether those vouchers will keep pace with rising health care costs.  Make no mistake, his policies and proposals reflect choices.  He believes that saving money for rich people and their businesses beats providing the most basic aid to poor people.  There is no other explanation for these policies.  What makes them especially abhorrent is that Mr. Ryan has no personal life experience that would justify the extraordinary degree of certainty he brings to policy positions that work such harsh consequences on the most vulnerable in our society. Even the Catholic Bishops take issue with the morality of his budget choices.

I also have yet to see justification for the claim that he is the “detail” man for the Republicans on budget issues.  In searching these documents, I see a massive tax cut with lots of gaps on how these cuts will be funded.  I also see gaps in Mr. Ryan’s perspective.  Like his running mate, he has never had to wonder whether his family will be safe financially.  He has not had to consider life without health insurance or walking to work in a crime-ridden neighborhood.  I don’t think his safety net has every been in real jeopardy.  From what I can tell, he has not held a job in the private sector since high school.  And while you could say the same thing about me on many of these points, the difference is that I know it.  What makes these guys scary is that they believe their own success justifies policies that rely upon a creed that says the path to success for all Americans can follow a route similar to theirs.  When it comes to making decisions on how the most vulnerable in our society will be treated, I think I will cast my lot with the guy whose character was forged in more challenging circumstances and whose perspective casts a pessimistic eye on the idea that investing in our richest citizens will somehow benefit the least of us.


Filed under Uncategorized

4 responses to “Ryan Deserves Your Scrutiny

  1. kelly

    I would simply offer one comment to your observation regarding the Presidents ‘more challenging circumstances.’ He attended private school in Indonesia, he attended an exclusive private prep school in Hawaii thru high school graduation, he attended Columbia and Harvard. His mother was a Phd, and father was a well-educated African economist. We could all benefit from such ‘challenging circumstances.’

    • No question he was given an opportunity to seize and he did. I still think that having your father check out of your life before you are out of diapers, and having your mother move you to a foreign country with a new foreign husband, and then sending you back when you are 10 to live with your grandparents is a challenge. Assimilating into Indonesia as a mixed race american kid who did not speak the language had to have been difficult at times. My point is that I think that experience presented a few more hurdles than his opponent’s upbringing and imbued him with a perspective that I trust as being considerate of the most disadvantaged among us.

  2. Craig W

    “His current proposal radically cuts funding to Medicaid by making Medicaid a block grant program.”

    Three questions:

    1. When you say his proposal radically “cuts” funding, what do you mean by “cuts?” Do you mean capping future growth to a level below where it is projected to be without the change (meaning that the actual number in the future may still be higher than today), or do you mean an actual cut in the number from today’s baseline (so that the actual number in the future is less than the number today)?

    2. Romney & the Republicans are saying that under PPACA, Medicare will be “cut” by ~$500B (“Cut” apparently refers to a lower increase rate from current baseline & projections, not an actual cut in the actual number from today to the future).

    3. With no changes to Medicare or other entitlements, which everyone understands when not in campaign mode are “unsustainable”, what service will be available to us, our children or theirs?

  3. Pingback: Paul Ryan Won’t Talk Specifics | astheworldbyrnes

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s